Susanna Calkins, Author
  • Home
  • Lucy Campion Mysteries
    • A Murder at Rosamund's Gate
    • From the Charred Remains
    • The Masque of a Murderer
    • A Death Along the River Fleet
    • The Sign of the Gallows
    • The Cry of the Hangman
    • Death Among the Ruins
  • The Speakeasy Murders
    • Murder Knocks Twice
    • The Fate of a Flapper
  • Short Stories
  • Blog
  • News & Events
    • Event Photos
    • Archived Guest Posts & Interviews
  • The Roaring Twenties
  • 17th c. England
  • Writing Resources
  • Nonfiction
  • New Page

From author to reader, from reader to viewer--what happens to a character?

1/15/2012

16 Comments

 
Picture
Did Scarlett J. do this character justice?
_After I viewed the trailer for Hunger Games, I admit I breathed a great sigh of relief. The young woman playing Katniss (Jennifer Lawrence) seemed spot on, as did the young man in the role of Gale (Liam Hemsworth).   I have to say, too, that Peeta (Josh Hutcherson) looked better than what I imagined. The movie looked exciting, and more importantly, seemed true to this tense and unpredictable book.

Why was I worried, you might ask.

Like every reader, I had imagined these vivid characters--and the whole world--in a certain way, bringing my own sensibilities and experience into the book.  Sometimes, it's really hard when an actor seems all wrong for the character. (Case in point--I enjoyed Matthew Macfadyen in MI-5, but I think he really misunderstood Mr. Darcy in Pride and Prejudice--and not just because the wonderful Colin Firth had already dominated the role). 


I always wonder what it's like for authors to see how others view their characters.  Perhaps sometimes the characters dance off the pages, just as they'd imagined, while at other times emerge as virtual strangers.

For my part,  I garner physical descriptions for my characters by seeking out visual cues.  Sometimes I rely on period art, as I think Tracy Chevalier may have done with Vermeer's The Girl with a Pearl Earring, to get a feel for how someone in early modern England might dress or wear their hair, and to ponder their worldview.  More often than not, I find photos of real actors to help me remember what each of my characters is "supposed to" look like, at least to me.

Hmmm...I could share those photos and images, if I wanted to. I'm pretty sure, however,  it's cheating when you tell readers how they are supposed to think. 

So as a writer, I'll stay hands-off about my own characters. I accept that characters are negotiated through the lenses that readers bring to the text.


As a reader, I admit I often don't want that negotiation to happen. I want to see on the big screen exactly what I see in my mind's eye. Otherwise, I'm confused, even disappointed.  Johnny Depp as Willy Wonka?  George Clooney as Batman?  Jim Carrey as the Grinch? I'm not so sure.

But sometimes characters evolve from author to reader to  viewer, when in deft hands. Consider Matt Damon as Jason Bourne. Robert Downey Jr. as Sherlock. Emily Deschanel as Temperance Brennan. And yes, Scarlett Johansson as Griet, the Girl with a Pearl Earring. None of these characters were really rendered as the author wrote them, and yet I was satisfied, even intrigued, in their re-imagining. 

The problem at that point, of course, is when everyone says: 'I think the characters were better in the movie than in the book." ARGHHHH!

What do you think? Have you ever been surprised--pleasantly or unpleasantly--when a character is portrayed very differently than what you had imagined?

16 Comments
Matt
1/15/2012 09:49:34 pm

Although I certainly form mental images of the book characters, I think they are rarely fully formed (visually) in my mind. Saying that they are 'faceless' may be going a bit too far, but really they are visually quite malleable--just a bit more than a default template with the right height, weight, hair, and general disposition.

For this reason, I think I've only rarely taken issue with how these characters have been cast in films. The bigger issue, as you mentioned, is when the actor seems to interpret the character incorrectly (e.g., Macfayden; Carrey). Occassionally, I will feel someone has been miscast (Affleck as Jack Ryan; Maquire as Spiderman), but then I enjoy the portrayal anyway.



Reply
Susie link
1/19/2012 09:46:01 am

yes, Ben Affleck (Hooflick!) seemed a little off for me too. I never had much of a vision though of Spiderman, so Maquire seemed nerdy enough to me.

Reply
Jennie
1/15/2012 09:52:44 pm

Susie!
This is such a fun post, because I think this is something most people can relate to or at least have thought about! It's always a good discussion. It seems like there is always some sort of debate about characters in books vs. the characters in the movies. You do always want the movie to be how you imagined the book, but like you said, it can sometimes be disappointing. It's kind of like with Harry Potter, I was super super pleased with the way they made those movies! It was everything I ever imagined HP to be. It'll be interesting to see what the Hunger Games is like. Even with the 'The Help,' I really enjoyed the book (I know you thought it was okay :-) ) and I was kind of slightly hesitant to see the movie (even though I was definitely going to see it anyway), but I was worried about how the filmmakers were going to portray the characters and I was really afraid they were going to lose something and ruin them! But I was pleasantly surprised at the portrayal of the all the characters, and really loved the movie.

Now I'm sure there is a movie where I was disappointed by the characters - I never did see the Johnny Depp Willy Wonka and never need to. George Clooney Batman was actually pretty awful. And I really do not like the new telling of How the Grinch Stole Christmas through Jim Carrey (give me the classic cartoon!). I'm sure there are probably more, I just can't think of!!! :-)

Reply
Susie link
1/19/2012 09:49:17 am

Jennie, I felt the same way about Harry Potter. I was quite nervous that they would not do the books justice, and they did! One of my friends never thought Daniel Radcliffe was quite right (too handsome, she thought from the covers he always looked a bit straggly, wild and crazy), but I was okay with him too. Thanks for stopping by!

Reply
Matt
1/16/2012 06:12:58 am

Regarding the Hunger Games trailer, I agree with you. I thought the characters and the whole feel seemed spot on to what I imagined. While reading all 3 books, I found that my image of Peeta kept changing. By the end, he ended up matching the actor pretty well.

Reply
Susie link
1/19/2012 09:51:27 am

Matt, when I first encountered Peeta I got an Augustus Gloop-like character in my mind, but as he showed himself to be more eloquent and reflective (and selfless), I was having a hard time placing him.

Reply
bekerys
1/19/2012 03:49:59 am

Another interesting post. I admit, I have in my head how certain characters should look, based on my interpretation of whatever description the author supplied with regard to height, coloring, build and so on. So when the awesome Indiana Jones (I mean, Harrison Ford) was cast as Jack Ryan when Alec Baldwin was unavailable, I could not get over it. I may have been scarred for life. Of course, if the film came first, or I saw the film before reading the book, I will usually just plug in the actor's face when visualizing the character's appearance.

Reply
Susie link
1/19/2012 09:54:21 am

Beckery--what did you think about Ben Affleck as Jack Ryan? Hmmm... Alec Baldwin was great. But maybe if we'd seen harrison ford in the role first, it would be different as you say. I guess its the same for people who get upset when James Bond changes. what about Jake Lloyd as baby Vader? :-)

Reply
bekerys
1/24/2012 03:53:42 am

Never saw Ben A playing Jack Ryan. Sorry--I don't like his acting style, and that was a major turn-off to seeing the movie. I really liked the little kid who played Anakin. He was great in the show "The Pretender" in the 90's. I thought at the end of the movie, he had the perfect expression of rage, determination, and conviction. I could believe this kid was going to do really great or really bad things; nothing run-of-the-mill for him.

Susie link
1/24/2012 12:21:54 pm

Surely he was too cute to be Darth Vader? Come on! Although as I watching the movies again, I did wonder how much bad stuff Vader actually did, and how much was done by the Emperor.

Lina :-)
1/19/2012 12:34:24 pm

That is why I don't like movies. I always feel uncertain; almost resistance going to movies adapted from books. And once I accept the characters, I then start to get nervous about the story. Is it going to be faithful to the book? Is it going to miss the important parts? Harry Potter is the only one that I feel....well, not so disappointed. Even so, every night when I listen to the story (yes, I am in Book 3 now again!), I ask myself, "Why wasn't this part included in the movie? What a shame!" Then I sleep with the book/audiobook; satisfied and happy.

Btw,for my curiosity and vanity, is this blog the after thought about our conversation about "Do you look like your name?" :-)

Reply
Susie link
1/19/2012 10:25:46 pm

Lina--did our conversation about the trailer lead to our conversation about names? Can't remember which came first. Regardless, I'm sure it was all swirling around in my head when I sat down to blog :-) Hey any ideas about what I should blog about next?

Reply
Lina
1/20/2012 12:44:12 pm

In fact, I have been thinking about writing "Blog, Blogging and Blogger". Want to write something about it? I need some inspiration and some sleep first though. :-)

Susie link
1/21/2012 12:15:59 am

the notion of blog and voice is interesting. We do have different voices when we write for different audiences; is one more legitimate than another? I'll file that away... :-)

Anna
1/25/2012 10:03:06 am

I really like this post. I feel very proprietary about certain characters, and I can therefore get quite upset when someone doesn't fit my image. In some cases, I also get attached to a particular performance. Case in point: Jeremy Brett as Sherlock Holmes. But these things are not insurmountable--I loved the new "Sherlock" series on the BBC, and I felt that Cumberbatch and Freeman both made the parts their own.

Another tough one--Jane Eyre. My favorite filmed version of that is the Timothy Dalton one from the 80s. Even though Dalton is too good-looking to fit the book's Rochester, he really gives a wonderful performance--and the script hews close to the actual text, which I think helps.

Reply
Susie link
1/26/2012 01:00:38 am

Anna, I love the new Sherlock on BBC (and Watson for that matter), for me, that modernization worked. Since I was always more of a Austen and Alcott fan than a Bronte fan, I didn't have a huge attachment to Jane Eyre myself (in fact, I remember when I read it as a teenager I was quite annoyed that they were together...but I've come to appreciate the beauty of the story over time). have you seen the 2011 movie--I haven't. I think there was another version I liked too--a more recent miniseries. In fact, this might be the rare example of me appreciating a book more after I saw the screen version :-)

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Susanna Calkins

    Historian. Mystery writer. Researcher. Teacher.  Occasional blogger.

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    1660s
    16th Century
    17th Century
    18th Century
    1910s
    1920s
    19th C.
    20th Century
    21st Century
    A Death Along The River Fleet
    Advertisements
    Alcohol
    Alpha Reader
    Amazon Pre Order
    Amazon Pre-order
    A Murder At Rosamund's Gate
    Anagrams
    Anne Perry
    Anthology
    Art
    Authorship
    Award
    Awards
    Blogger's Block
    Blogging
    Blog Hop
    Blog Tour
    Bloody Good Read
    Bombings
    Book Events
    Book Giveaway
    Booksellers
    Book Trade
    Bouchercon
    Calendars
    Card Playing
    Caricature
    Cats
    Chambermaid
    Characters
    Charles I
    Charles Ii
    Charles Todd
    Chicago
    Chocolate
    Christmas
    Cia
    Cockney Slang
    Cocktails
    Coffee
    Coincidence
    Contemporary
    Cover Design
    Covers
    Creativity
    Crime
    Criminals
    Critical Thinking
    Cromwell
    Crossroads
    Csikszentmihalyi
    Cuckold
    Curiosities
    Defoe
    Detectives
    Detectives Oath
    Disease
    Dogs
    Early Modern
    Easter
    Editing
    Edwardian England
    Etymology
    Examples
    Excerpt Marg
    Excerpts
    Fairs
    Fate Of A Flapper
    Feedback
    Female Protagonists
    Female Sleuths
    Fire Of London
    Flow
    Food
    Forensics
    Forms Of Address
    French History
    From The Charred Remains
    Ftcr
    Future
    Games
    Gangs
    Giveaways
    Golden Hind
    Great Fire
    Great War
    Grit
    Guest Blogs
    Guest Interviews
    Guest Post
    Guest Posts
    Guilds
    Hanging
    Historical Fiction
    Historical Mysteries
    History
    Imagination
    Inspiration
    Interviews
    Ireland
    ITW Authors
    Jests
    Jewelry
    Language
    Last Dying Speeches
    Leisure
    Libraries
    London Bridge
    Lucy Campion
    Macavity
    Magistrate
    Malice Domestic
    Maps
    MARG
    Markets
    Masque Of A Murderer
    Matg
    Medicine
    Medieval
    Medieval Period
    Memory
    Merriments
    Merry-making
    Methodists
    Midwives
    Mindset
    Miscellany
    Monsters
    Moonstone
    Motivation
    Murder
    Murder At Rosamund's Gate
    Murder Ballad
    Murder Knocks Twice
    Mysteries
    Mystery
    Mystery Tv Shows
    Newgate
    Newspapers
    New Woman
    Nietzsche
    Nursery Rhymes
    Opera
    Orwell
    Persistence
    Pets
    Philadelphia
    Piracy
    Pirates
    Plagiarism
    Plague
    Poison
    Popular Film
    Popular Press
    Potions
    Printers Row Lit Fest
    Printing
    Private Investigators
    Proactive Interference
    Procrastination
    Prohibition
    Promoting Books
    Pseudonyms
    Psychology
    Publication
    Public Executions
    Publishing
    Punishments
    Puritans
    Puzzles
    Quakers
    Radio Shows
    Reader Questions
    Reading
    Receipts
    Reformation
    Rejection
    Religion
    Research
    Restoration
    Riddles
    River Fleet
    Samuel Pepys
    Scene Development
    Science Fiction
    Scold's Bridle
    Secret London
    Setting
    Seven Things
    Shakespeare
    Short Story
    Sign Of The Gallows
    Sleuths In Time
    Smithfield
    Speakeasy Mysteries
    Speech
    Spying
    Strange Things
    Teaching
    Thank You
    The 1640s
    The 1650s
    The 1660s
    Theater
    Thief-taker
    Timeline
    Titles
    Travel
    True Crime
    Tyburn Tree
    Valentine
    Wilkie Collins
    Winchester Palace
    Witches
    Women
    World-building
    Writier's Life
    Writing
    Writing Prompts
    Young Adult

    Archives

    February 2021
    January 2020
    December 2019
    August 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    September 2018
    November 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    November 2016
    September 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011

    RSS Feed

  • Home
  • Lucy Campion Mysteries
    • A Murder at Rosamund's Gate
    • From the Charred Remains
    • The Masque of a Murderer
    • A Death Along the River Fleet
    • The Sign of the Gallows
    • The Cry of the Hangman
    • Death Among the Ruins
  • The Speakeasy Murders
    • Murder Knocks Twice
    • The Fate of a Flapper
  • Short Stories
  • Blog
  • News & Events
    • Event Photos
    • Archived Guest Posts & Interviews
  • The Roaring Twenties
  • 17th c. England
  • Writing Resources
  • Nonfiction
  • New Page